
A review of a movie, or a restaurant, or a car—or whatever else that typically falls under a critic's domain—is all well and good, and can even be helpful at times. But how can one find out about myriad other experiences that are never tackled in reviews? Enter Forrest MacNeil, a critic who goes beyond overviews of life's more-common subjects—way beyond—to satisfy the curiosity of others: The adrenaline rush of stealing; the danger of drug addiction; the delight of sleeping with a celebrity. MacNeil tries anything suggested by viewers of his TV show, then presents a 1-to-5-star review. But his unwavering commitment to experiencing intense adventures means he must deal with the unintended consequences of such a goal.






Forrest gets carried away while reviewing theft, finds that his threshold for addiction is high except when it comes to cocaine and takes his son's babysitter to prom.
Forrest makes a sex tape, tries his hand at being a racist and goes hunting with his father-in-law.
Forrest hits rock bottom after divorcing Suzanne and forcing himself to eat an unhealthy number of pancakes.
Forrest bids a fortune to win a dinner with Ashley Tisdale and learns the secret to being Batman from his disastrous family court proceedings.
Forrest goes to space with his ex-father-in-law and competes in a friend-off to become his neighbor Gene's best friend.
Forrest unleashes his inner f**kbeast at an orgy and finds that road rage can quickly turn ugly.
Forrest seeks revenge on a classmate from middle school, attends a self-actualization seminar and struggles with the meaning of an incomprehensible request.
Forrest's marriage to a woman he just met complicates his life as the two of them go on the run from the law and throw a party at their communal living house.
Forrest becomes deeply invested in a new job that he's obligated to quit, lives a day as if it's his last and receives an ultimatum from Suzanne while pretending to be Irish.
Forrest gets into a fight with a stranger, blackmails his new girlfriend and discovers the pleasures of a glory hole.
Forrest attempts to turn a young gay man straight and finds that having sex on an airplane is surprisingly difficult.
Forrest has Josh frame him for a crime, has sex with a high school teacher and experiences the everyday struggles of being a little person.
Forrest gathers followers for his new cult and begins a regimen of bodily enhancements in the pursuit of physical perfection.
Forrest reconnects with an old flame during his first foray into catfishing and discovers a variety of ghosts while spending the night in a haunted house.
Forrest wrangles his father into recreating William Tell's bow-and-arrow feat, reluctantly makes his son's birthday wish comes true and spends time in a rowboat.
Forrest spends 24 hours in a coffin, faces a dilemma when a viewer asks him to rate something with six stars and speaks at Suzanne's rehearsal dinner.
Forrest allows a Magic 8-Ball to dictate his decisions for a day, runs into a paradox when faced with the task of procrastinating and faces his toughest review yet.
Forrest experiments with being relentlessly upbeat and conducts two reviews from a difficult location.
Forrest makes a disconcerting discovery while researching conspiracy theories and ends up on the run from a man hunter.
Forrest accepts a challenge from a Mexican restaurant chain's marketing department, searches for a pet to put to sleep and lives one of his dreams.
Forrest switches places with A.J. Gibbs; lives as a blind and deaf person; and misunderstands a viewer's request to understand what forgiveness is like.
Forrest has himself frozen, makes himself into a human lightning rod and gets pranked.